Fair Disciplinary Hearings
How to run a hearing that is fair to your employee and will stand up at the Industrial Court
Dismissal disputes made up 86.6% of all new cases filed at the Industrial Court between September 2025 and September 2026. In my experience, most of them aren't lost because the employer had no reason to act. They're lost because of how the employer acted: the worker was never told the charge, never saw the evidence, or never had a real chance to answer. A fair hearing is your best protection, and it's also the right way to treat people.
What the law expects
The Industrial Relations Act (Chap. 88:01) gives the Industrial Court wide powers over dismissals:
- The Court must make the order it considers fair and just, acting on equity, good conscience and the substantial merits of the case, and having regard to the principles and practices of good industrial relations (section 10(3)).
- Where a worker was dismissed in circumstances that were harsh and oppressive, or not in accordance with good industrial relations practice, the Court can order reinstatement or re-employment, or award compensation (sections 10(4) and 10(5)).
- The Court assesses compensation as it considers fair, without being bound by the usual rules on damages, and its assessment can't be appealed to another court (sections 10(5) and 10(6)).
In short: having a good reason isn't enough. The process has to be fair too.
The six things a fair hearing needs
These six points come from the rules of natural justice and the good industrial relations practice the Industrial Court applies. They are not a list set out in the Act.
- 1
A proper investigation first.
Establish the facts before you decide anything. See Fact-Finding Investigations and Chapter 20.
- 2
The charge, in writing.
The worker must know exactly what they are accused of: what, when and where. Never call someone to a meeting without telling them its true purpose.
- 3
The evidence, in advance.
Give the worker the investigation findings and any statements you will rely on, with enough time to prepare.
- 4
A real chance to answer.
Let the worker give their side, call witnesses and question the evidence against them.
- 5
An open-minded decision-maker.
Where you can, the person who decides should not be the person who investigated, or the person who made the complaint.
- 6
A chance to plead in mitigation.
Before you decide the penalty, ask the worker if there is anything you should take into account, such as their length of service, record or personal circumstances.
Step by step
Before the hearing
At the hearing
After the hearing
Suspension: keep it short and fair
If you need the worker away from the workplace while you investigate:
- Suspend on full pay, unless a collective agreement or contract clearly says otherwise
- Put it in writing, and say it is not a penalty
- Give a review date, and keep the suspension as short as possible
- Don't leave a worker suspended indefinitely while nothing happens
Don't punish the same thing twice
If a worker has already been warned for something, you can't later dismiss them for the same incident. The Court treats that as a second penalty for the same offence, or double jeopardy. A new incident is different, and a previous warning can be taken into account for that.
What about representation?
The Industrial Relations Act doesn't set out a general right to be accompanied at an internal disciplinary hearing. But inviting the worker to bring a union representative or a colleague is good industrial relations practice, and in a unionised workplace the collective agreement will usually require it. Always offer it, and give the worker reasonable time to arrange it.
Lessons from recent cases
| Case | What went wrong | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Willoughby's Travel Services (Industrial Court, 2025) | A worker with about 26 years' service was dismissed without being told of further proceedings or given a chance to plead in mitigation, for conduct she had already been warned about | Double jeopardy; TT$200,000 in damages |
| Colvin Refrigeration (Industrial Court, 2024) | The charges were never put to the worker, she never saw the investigation findings, and she was suspended without pay for most of a year | Harsh and oppressive; TT$385,000 in damages |
| UDECOTT (Court of Appeal, 2025) | The worker wasn't told the true purpose of the meeting she was called to, the allegations weren't properly investigated, and her good record was ignored | The Court of Appeal upheld the award against the employer |
| PSA v WASA (Court of Appeal, 2023) | The worker was not heard in mitigation before being dismissed | Sent back to the Industrial Court to decide whether this made the dismissal harsh and oppressive |
Source: Feature address by the President of the Industrial Court, Review of 2025 Judgments, 15 April 2026.
If the dismissal is challenged
- A dismissal dispute is reported to the Minister of Labour by a trade union (the recognised union, or the worker's own union if there is no recognised union). An individual worker can't report it directly.
- It must be reported within six months of the dismissal, although the Minister can extend this.
- The Ministry will first try to settle it through conciliation. If that fails, it can go to the Industrial Court.
- Some people aren't "workers" under the Act, such as household employees and senior staff responsible for policy. They may still bring a claim in the High Court under their contract.
Your hearing notes, letters and investigation report will be your main evidence, so keep them all.
Red flags: stop and check before you dismiss
If you tick any of these, pause and fix it before you decide.
Related
Based on the Industrial Relations Act, Chap. 88:01, and recent decisions of the Industrial Court and Court of Appeal. General guidance only, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.