Back

Fact-Finding Investigations

How to find out what happened, fairly, before you decide anything

When something goes wrong at work, a complaint, an incident, money missing, the natural reaction is to act quickly. The safer thing is to find out what happened first. In my experience, an investigation that was skipped, rushed or one-sided is one of the most common reasons employers lose at the Industrial Court, even when the employee really did something wrong. This guide takes you through a fact-finding investigation step by step, with the questions to ask and the letters to send.

Where this fits

This guide covers the investigation stage: finding the facts. Chapter 20 sets out the principles, the investigation report template and short interview guides. Once the facts are found, Fair Disciplinary Hearings covers the hearing and the decision.

What a fact-finding investigation is (and isn't)

A fact-finding investigation gathers the facts so that someone can make a fair decision. It is:

  • neutral: no one has been found to have done anything wrong yet
  • about evidence: what people saw, heard and did, and what the documents show
  • decided on the balance of probabilities: is it more likely than not that it happened?

It is not a disciplinary hearing, and it doesn't decide a penalty. If the facts show there's a case to answer, that goes to a separate hearing, ideally run by someone else.

When should an investigation begin?

As soon as reasonably possible after you become aware of the complaint or incident, and before you take any disciplinary step.

  • Acknowledge the complaint, in writing, within a day or two.
  • Decide within a few working days whether it needs an informal look or a formal investigation.
  • Don't let it sit. Memories fade, evidence like CCTV gets recorded over, and a long delay can look as though you accepted the conduct. It can also leave the employee under a cloud for months, which the Court may see as unfair.

Informal or formal?

Informal lookFormal investigation
Use it forMinor, first-time issues; misunderstandings; small disagreements between colleaguesAllegations of serious misconduct (theft, fraud, violence, harassment, discrimination); formal grievances against a named person; safety incidents; anything that could lead to a written warning or dismissal
Who handles itThe supervisor or managerAn impartial investigator with no involvement in the matter
What happensA private conversation with the people involvedWritten allegation, separate interviews, evidence collected, signed statements, written report
What's recordedA short dated note on fileA full investigation file and report
Possible outcomeGuidance, a conversation, mediation, no further actionA recommendation on whether there is a case to answer at a disciplinary hearing

If an informal look uncovers something more serious, stop and start a formal investigation.

Step by step

  1. Write down the allegation. What is alleged to have happened, when, where and who was involved. Describe the facts only; don't label it as misconduct.
  2. Choose the investigator. Someone impartial, with no involvement in the matter and no stake in the outcome. In a very small business, or where a senior manager is involved, consider an outside investigator.
  3. Decide whether to suspend. Only if the employee's presence could affect the investigation or put people or property at risk. Suspend on full pay, in writing, say it isn't a penalty, and set a review date. See Fair Disciplinary Hearings.
  4. Secure the evidence. CCTV, emails, messages, cash records, time records, system logs. Save copies straight away, before they're deleted or recorded over.
  5. Plan the interviews. Usually the complainant first, then witnesses, then the employee the allegation is about. Prepare your questions (see the question bank below).
  6. Invite the employee in writing. Tell them what the allegation is, the date and time of the meeting, and that no decision has been made. Use the invitation letter below.
  7. Hold the interviews separately. Use the same opening statement each time (see Chapter 20). Ask open questions, take notes, and let each person tell their story.
  8. Have each record signed. Give each person their interview record to read, correct and sign. If they won't sign, note that, and note why.
  9. Follow up on new points. If someone raises something new, check it. If new evidence affects the employee under investigation, put it to them and let them respond.
  10. Write the report. Allegation, process, evidence, findings of fact for each point, and whether there's a case to answer. Use the template in Chapter 20.
  11. Hand over. Give the report to the decision-maker. If there's a case to answer, they arrange a disciplinary hearing. If not, tell the employee in writing that the matter is closed.

Fact-finding meeting questions

Good questions are open: they let people tell you what happened in their own words. A simple rule: start questions with Tell me, Explain or Describe, then follow up with who, what, when, where and how.

Questions that work in any interview

  • “Tell me in your own words what happened.”
  • “Take me through it from the beginning. What happened first?”
  • “Describe exactly what you saw and heard.”
  • “Who else was there?”
  • “When was this? How do you know it was that day or time?”
  • “Where exactly were you standing, and could you see clearly?”
  • “What happened next?”
  • “What did you do afterwards? Did you tell anyone?”
  • “Is there anything written down, a message, an email, a photo, that relates to this?”
  • “Is there anyone else I should speak to?”
  • “Is there anything I haven't asked that you think I should know?”

For the person who made the complaint

  • “Describe what happened, as much detail as you can remember.”
  • “Has anything like this happened before? Tell me about each time.”
  • “How did it affect you, and your work?”
  • “Have you raised this with anyone before? What happened?”
  • “What would you like to happen now?”

For a witness

  • “Tell me what you personally saw or heard.”
  • “How far away were you, and what were you doing at the time?”
  • “Is that something you saw yourself, or something someone told you?”
  • “Have you talked about this with anyone since? Who?”

For the employee the allegation is about

  • “You've had the allegation in writing. Tell me your account of what happened.”
  • “Were you there at the time? What were you doing?”
  • “Is there any part of the allegation you disagree with? Tell me why.”
  • “Is there anything that would help explain what happened?”
  • “Is there anyone who could support your account, or any documents I should look at?”
  • “Is there anything else you want me to take into account?”

Extra questions for common situations

Harassment or bullying

  • “What exactly was said or done? Tell me the words used, as closely as you remember.”
  • “How often has this happened, and over what period?”
  • “Did you say or show that it was unwelcome? How?”

Missing money, stock or property

  • “Walk me through how cash (or stock) is handled on your shift, step by step.”
  • “Who else had access to the till, safe, store room or keys during that time?”
  • “Describe what you did when you found the shortage.”

Safety incident or accident

  • “Describe the task you were doing, and how you normally do it.”
  • “What equipment and protective gear were being used?”
  • “Had anything like this happened before, or been reported?”

Time and attendance

  • “Describe how you record your start and finish times.”
  • “Tell me about the days in question. Where were you, and who can confirm it?”

Questions to avoid

AvoidAsk instead
“You took the money, didn't you?”“Tell me what happened at the till that afternoon.”
“Did he shout at you because he was angry?”“Describe how he spoke to you.”
“Everyone says you were late. Why?”“Tell me about your start times that week.”
“Why would she lie about this?”“Is there anything that would help explain the difference between your accounts?”
“Don't you think that was inappropriate?”“How did you see that situation at the time?”
Two questions at once: “Where were you, and who were you with?”Ask one question, wait for the answer, then ask the next.

Leading questions put words in people's mouths, and can make the evidence unreliable. Let silences sit; people often add the most important detail after a pause.

Fairness: what the law expects

  • Good industrial relations practice. When it decides a dismissal case, the Industrial Court looks at whether the employer followed good industrial relations practice, and whether the dismissal was harsh and oppressive (Industrial Relations Act, section 10). A fair investigation is a big part of that.
  • The right to respond. The employee must know what the allegation is and have a real chance to give their side before any decision is made.
  • Representation. The law doesn't give a general right to bring someone to an internal investigation meeting. But if your collective agreement, policy or the employee's contract allows a union representative or colleague, follow it. Allowing one is usually good practice and makes the process harder to challenge.
  • Confidentiality. Share information only with those who need it. Ask everyone you interview to keep it confidential.
  • No retaliation. Make it clear that no one will be treated badly for making a complaint in good faith or giving evidence. If it happens, treat it as a separate disciplinary matter.
  • Safety incidents. If someone died or was critically injured, the OSH Act also requires you to tell the Chief Inspector straight away, and in writing within 48 hours (section 46). Don't disturb the scene more than safety requires.

Templates

1. Invitation to an investigation meeting (employee the allegation is about)

Private and confidential

Dear [Name],

Investigation meeting

We have received [a complaint / a report] that on [date], at [place], you [describe the allegation factually, for example: were absent from your post between 2pm and 4pm without permission].

We are investigating this to find out what happened. No decision has been made, and this meeting is not a disciplinary hearing.

I would like to meet with you on [date] at [time] at [place] so that you can give your account. Please bring any documents or information you think are relevant, and tell me of anyone you think I should speak to.

[If your policy or collective agreement allows: You may bring a colleague or a union representative with you.]

Please keep this matter confidential and do not discuss it with others who may be involved.

If you can't attend at this time, please let me know by [date] so that we can agree another time.

Yours sincerely,
[Name]
[Job title]

2. Invitation to a witness interview

Private and confidential

Dear [Name],

We are looking into a workplace matter that took place on [date], and I understand you may have information that could help. I would like to meet with you on [date] at [time] at [place].

You are not in any trouble. I would only ask about what you personally saw or heard. Please keep this matter, and our meeting, confidential.

Yours sincerely,
[Name]
[Job title]

3. Suspension on full pay pending investigation

Private and confidential

Dear [Name],

Suspension on full pay pending investigation

As you were told on [date], we are investigating an allegation that [describe the allegation factually].

While we investigate, you are suspended from work on full pay with effect from [date]. This is not a disciplinary penalty, and no decision has been made about the allegation. We have taken this step because [give the reason, for example: we need to review records you have access to / to protect the investigation].

During your suspension, please do not come to the workplace or contact colleagues about this matter, unless we have agreed it with you. You will continue to receive your normal pay and benefits. Please remain available to attend meetings during your normal working hours.

We will review your suspension on [review date] and keep you informed.

If you have any questions, please contact [name and phone number].

Yours sincerely,
[Name]
[Job title]

No law sets a fixed length for a suspension pending investigation, but the Industrial Court has found long, open-ended suspensions harsh and oppressive. Check your collective agreement or policy first, as it may set a limit. If yours doesn't, a review within about two weeks is good practice.

4. Interview record

Matter reference:
Name of person interviewed:
Role: Complainant / Witness / Employee the allegation is about
Date, start time and end time:
Place:
Investigator:
Note-taker:
Others present (for example a union representative):
Account given (in the person's own words as far as possible):
Documents or evidence provided:
Other people named:

I have read this record of my interview. It is a true and accurate account of what I said, with any corrections I have initialled.

Signature of person interviewed: ______ Date: ______

Signature of investigator: ______ Date: ______

If the person won't sign, write 'Declined to sign' and the reason they gave, and date it.

5. Outcome: no case to answer

Private and confidential

Dear [Name],

Outcome of investigation

I am writing about the investigation into the allegation that [describe the allegation], which we discussed on [date].

The investigation is now complete. I have found that there is no case to answer, and no further action will be taken. [If you were suspended: Your suspension ends, and you should return to work on [date].]

Thank you for your cooperation. Please continue to keep this matter confidential.

Yours sincerely,
[Name]
[Job title]

If there is a case to answer, use the hearing invitation letter in Chapter 21 instead.

Common mistakes

  • Deciding the outcome before speaking to the employee
  • Not telling the employee what the allegation is, or telling them only at the meeting
  • The same person investigating, deciding and hearing the appeal
  • Interviewing people together, so their accounts merge
  • Leading questions that put words in people's mouths
  • No notes, or notes that weren't read and signed
  • Letting CCTV or messages be deleted before they were saved
  • Leaving an employee suspended for weeks with nothing happening
  • Not checking new points that come up in the interviews
  • Talking about the investigation with people who don't need to know

For employees: what to expect at a fact-finding meeting

Checklist

Related

Based on the Industrial Relations Act, Chap. 88:01 (section 10), the Occupational Safety and Health Act, Chap. 88:08 (section 46), and the good industrial relations practice applied by the Industrial Court. General guidance only, not legal advice. Last reviewed November 2026.